Stuart Warner can help you write books, write narrative journalism or just write better
Author: Mr. Write Coach
Stuart Warner can help you become a better writer. Warner has developed a national reputation as an editor and journalism teacher. He has written or edited three Pulitzer Prize-winning entries and edited three other Pulitzer finalists As the writing coach at The Plain Dealer in Cleveland, he edited stories than won more than 50 national awards.
Currently, Warner teaches journalism at Case Western Reserve University and is a regular contributor to AOL.com. He has been honored numerous times for his own writing. He has also been invited to speak on writing at the Nieman narrative conference at Harvard, the Let’s Do It Better conference at Columbia University, the National Writers Workshop sponsored by the Poynter Institute, the IRE’s national Computer Assisted Reporting workshop and at Capitolbeat, the national seminar for state government reporters.
He has also worked with the writers at a number of companies, including Politifact, Key Bank, Signal Cleveland, the Akron Beacon Journal, Cleveland Jewish News, Akron General Hospital and also taught at Cleveland State University.
Two months ago I upset a few Facebookers when I posted about the tragic death of 20-year-old Haitian Pierre Damas Bel in Springfield, Ohio.
“He FOLLOWED the rules,” I wrote. “He was legal.”
Several were quick to point out that Pierre remained in this country this summer AFTER the Trump administration ended the Temporary Protected Status that had allowed Haitians like him to stay. They argued that he was no longer allowed to be in Ohio..
But now I wonder if he had managed to live to see Tuesday’s election, if he could have maintained hope.
Pierre was born in Haiti, the oldest of three children. His parents left Haiti about three years before Pierre came to the United States. They bought a home in Springfield. Pierre remained behind in Haiti until 2024.
He came here at 18 to rejoin his family and continue his education.
He had no idea that his life soon would be unbearable.
I had no direct connection to Pierre, but I came to know hundreds of children like him through the writing of Emily Troutman, an AOL News reporter I supervised for a year while she covered Haiti after the devastating Jan. 12, 2010, earthquake.
Emily wrote dozens of heartbreaking stories about displaced children surviving in unsanitary, makeshift communities, including this excerpt from six months after the earthquake:
“There are now more than 1,300 camps. They are filled with 700,000 tarps and 100,000 tents. They are tied up alongside 8,000 cubic yards of rubble and 190,000 destroyed houses. There are 1.5 million people, including half a million children, in the streets.”
Then she asked Haitians what they had been doing lately.
“Nou leve chak jou, epi nou chita.”
In Creole: We get up every day, and we sit back down.
Pierre would have been 4 or 5 years old then.
He had been getting up every day and doing his best since arriving in America.
On March 5, 2024, Pierre made an appointment through the government’s CBP One program. He presented himself at a port of entry in Brownsville, Texas. He was released into the U.S. while his immigration case proceeded.
He enrolled at Springfield High School, where he became a National Honor Society student, a varsity soccer player and a member of the Marine Corps JROTC. He earned a scholarship. He worked at a local Texas Roadhouse, where coworkers thought enough of him to write character letters for his immigration case.
After graduating from Springfield High in May, Pierre enrolled at Wright State University. He was studying neuroscience and intended to go to medical school. He hoped to continue playing soccer.
He followed the rules.
Then Washington changed them.
The Trump administration moved to terminate Haiti’s Temporary Protected Status. On June 25, the Supreme Court cleared the way. The protection ended July 27.
Two days later, ICE placed Pierre in its Alternatives to Detention program and fitted him with a GPS ankle monitor while his immigration case continued.
The next day, Pierre wrote publicly about his “shame and humiliation.” He said he had come to America for an education, not to commit crimes or hurt anyone.
His father later said Pierre felt he was being treated “like an animal.”
Pierre didn’t just complain about the monitor.
His father said Pierre made two trips to immigration offices asking officials to remove it. He worried about attending college wearing it. He worried about playing soccer.
His father said students ridiculed him because of the monitor. Wright State says it has no confirmed information about complaints or investigations involving bullying.
On Aug. 24, Pierre began classes at Wright State.
He had made it.
Neuroscience. College. Maybe medical school.
Eight days later, at 8:03 on the morning of Aug. 31, Pierre video-called his father and told him he wasn’t doing well mentally. His father told him to come home so they could talk.
Pierre parked his Toyota on the shoulder of Interstate 70.
He never made it home.
So I stand by what I wrote on Facebook.
Pierre was legal. He followed the rules.
Then the rules changed.
It’s time to change them back, so we don’t lose any more Pierres.
(Chat GPT-5.6 contributed to the research and editing of this column. It also created the illustration.)
Thirty-two years after the Akron Beacon Journal won a Pulitzer by embracing technology, its journalists are challenging their corporate owner with a byline strike over AI. Both sides should be asking a different question.
In the early 1990s, the future of journalism was scattered in piles around Bob Paynter’s desk.
Huge reels of magnetic tape, loaded with census and other data, surrounded the Akron Beacon Journal investigative editor’s workspace. Bob was among the pioneers of computer-assisted reporting, discovering how technology could help journalists uncover stories they might otherwise never find.
In the spring of 1992, after the riots following the Rodney King verdict, we decided to examine race relations in our own community. But we also learned that the much larger Plain Dealer was pursuing a similarly ambitious project. We knew we couldn’t match their resources or speed. So Bob, my wife, Deb Van Tassel, and four other journalists devised a different approach.
We enlisted the University of Akron’s political science department to survey residents about their attitudes toward race. Professional moderators conducted focus groups to explore what people really thought. Computer databases helped us examine demographic patterns. Reporters went into neighborhoods, interviewed residents and put human faces on the numbers.
The Plain Dealer published its fine series by the end of 1992. Our final installment didn’t appear until December 1993.
Four months later, the Beacon Journal won the Pulitzer Prize Gold Medal for Public Service for A Question of Color/Coming Together, an examination of racial divisions that helped launch a communitywide effort to confront them.
We didn’t win because computers replaced journalists. We won because technology helped good journalists do extraordinary work.
More than three decades later, journalists at that same newspaper are withholding their bylines to protest their corporate owner’s use of another emerging technology.
Artificial intelligence.
A legitimate complaint
Journalists at The Akron Beacon Journal and The Record-Courier in Kent are protesting DeeperDive, an AI-powered chatbot introduced by their corporate owner, USA TODAY Co., formerly Gannett. They began withholding their bylines from stories on Oct. 28. J
Journalists at other USA TODAY Co. newspapers, including the Columbus Dispatch, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel and Asbury Park Press, have also protested the company’s use of AI, calling for stronger editorial safeguards and greater journalist involvement in decisions about the technology.
The AI tool answers readers’ questions using newspaper content. According to the NewsGuild, the union that represents the local journalists, DeeperDive has produced inaccurate and misleading information, including an answer that mistakenly identified a journalist as a murder suspect.
If the Guild is correct that the company is violating its own standards requiring human verification of AI-generated content, the journalists have every reason to be angry.
I’ve spent much of my career on both sides of the newsroom divide. I was a Guild member in Akron before moving into management there, at the Plain Dealer and eventually at Gannett.
I understand the concerns of working journalists. I also understand the financial pressures facing newspaper companies, which have watched advertising revenue evaporate and newsroom staffs shrink.
But accuracy isn’t negotiable. Neither is accountability.
The problem isn’t that artificial intelligence makes mistakes. Human journalists make them, too. We misidentified a rape suspect in Akron back in the ’80s. The problem is publishing information without adequate safeguards to catch those mistakes.
The question shouldn’t be whether artificial intelligence belongs in journalism. It should be how journalists can use AI to produce better journalism.
USA TODAY executives have touted DeeperDive’s popularity, reporting millions of reader interactions and increased engagement. Those are encouraging business metrics. But they don’t tell us whether the technology is making the journalism itself more valuable to readers.
I understand why newspaper executives embrace technology that reduces costs. But cutting the cost of journalism and increasing its value are not the same thing.
In 1993, we didn’t ask how many reporters computers could replace. We asked what those computers could help our reporters accomplish.
It’s still the right question.
Artificial or augmented?
Artificial intelligence. Augmented intelligence.
One approach asks what machines can do instead of people. The other asks what people can accomplish with the help of machines.
An AI assistant can help a reporter examine thousands of public records, identify patterns, explore competing explanations and find weaknesses in a developing story.
They can challenge an editor’s assumptions, suggest alternative approaches and help turn a complicated subject into something readers can understand.
But they can’t be trusted to decide, on their own, what is true.
ChatGPT and I have collaborated on books, screenplays, business articles and columns. I use my assistant for research, brainstorming, editing and occasionally arguing.
Plenty of arguing.
Sometimes they offer an insight I hadn’t considered. Sometimes they challenge a weak premise or identify a hole in a narrative. And sometimes they produce something so spectacularly wrong that I wonder how anything supposedly intelligent could have come up with it.
That’s when I remind them who’s the boss.
The technology doesn’t replace my experience or judgment. It helps me put them to better use.
That’s augmented intelligence.
And I believe every reporter and editor should have an opportunity to develop that kind of working relationship with an AI assistant. It’s like having a writing coach at your side 24/7.
Give journalists the tools
Instead of fighting over whether we should use AI, work together to decide how to use it to make journalists more effective.
Give every reporter and editor access to a capable AI assistant, with appropriate protections for confidential sources and unpublished information. Provide training, encourage experimentation and give journalists time to discover what works.
Let the people who actually produce the journalism help establish the standards.
Make verification mandatory. Keep human editors responsible for what gets published. And distinguish between AI assisting a journalist and an automated chatbot communicating directly with the public.
A reporter can check an AI assistant’s work before using it. A chatbot answering thousands of reader questions may produce errors that no editor ever sees. If management can’t provide adequate safeguards for that second application, it shouldn’t be using it.
I don’t pretend that AI won’t change newsroom employment. It almost certainly will. But newspaper companies have spent decades trying to survive by producing journalism with fewer people.
Perhaps it’s time to ask whether technology could help the people who remain produce more ambitious, more valuable journalism instead.
That’s what we did in Akron.
The lesson from those tape reels
Our Pulitzer project wasn’t simply an exercise in technological innovation. Twenty-nine journalists and artists worked on A Question of Color. They challenged one another, argued over difficult decisions and ultimately produced journalism that reached far beyond the newspaper’s pages.
In the second phase of the project, Coming Together, thousands of residents joined efforts to improve race relations. The work helped change the conversation in Akron.
I find something reassuring about the current dispute. The journalists at my old newspaper are once again challenging a powerful institution, this time the corporation that employs them.
That independent spirit is worth preserving.
So is the willingness to embrace new ideas that helped make the Beacon Journal a great newspaper.
Those enormous reels of census data around Bob Paynter’s desk are long gone. The technology that once seemed revolutionary would be hopelessly primitive today.
But the principle hasn’t changed.
Give good journalists better tools. Encourage them to ask harder questions, pursue more ambitious stories and exercise their judgment.
We called it computer-assisted reporting in 1993.
Today, I’d call it augmented intelligence.
The future of journalism shouldn’t be measured by how many journalists AI can replace, but by how much better journalism those journalists can produce.
Veteran newspaper editor Stuart Warner worked with ChatGPT-6.0 to produce this article. Warner approved every word of the final version. We reached out to The Beacon Journal and a union representative for comments. The guild rep verified the story’s information. Management has not replied.
Thousands of spectators crowded into downtown Owensboro, Ky., on Aug. 14, 1936. Some climbed onto rooftops for a better view.
They had come to watch a man hang.
Rainey Bethea’s death is widely regarded as the last public hanging in America.
Ninety years later, Kentucky.com posted a photograph of the spectacle on its Facebook page. Readers quickly responded. Many gleefully.
“I’ll have the popcorn,” wrote one, adding two smiling devil emojis.
“Make it the halftime show of the army/navy football game,” suggested another.
Maybe Pete Hegseth, secretary of the How to Lose a War Department, is onto something.
Hegseth announced plans to livestream the execution of Nidal Hasan, the former Army psychiatrist convicted of murdering 13 people and wounding 32 others at Fort Hood, Texas, in 2009.
The execution is scheduled for Dec. 3.
The proposed method? A firing squad.
But why settle for one televised execution when there’s an entire entertainment franchise waiting to be created? We could have revenue streaming, too.
Consider the possibilities:
The Price Is Right. Contestants bid on premium viewing packages. Front-row seats. Commemorative blindfolds. Maybe even a chance to meet the firing squad. Proceeds benefit President Donald Trump’s White House ballroom and help finish the border wall.
Wheel of Misfortune. Spin the wheel to select the method of execution. Electric chair! Lethal injection! Hanging! Firing squad! Sorry, no bankruptcies. Only fatalities.
Double Jeopardy! Categories include Crime and Punishment, Famous Last Words and American History.
The contestants have already been convicted, so the answers don’t matter much.
And finally, the biggest show of them all.
The Accused.
Donald Trump returns to the format that made him a television star. Instead of aspiring executives competing for a job, convicted murderers compete for their lives.
The president sits behind his desk, studies the contestants and delivers his verdict.
“YOU GET THE FIRING SQUAD!”
Turn on the applause sign.
Break for commercials.
Pass the popcorn.
Of course, there’s one small problem with turning executions into entertainment.
People don’t always die on cue.
On Sept. 30, Tennessee prison officials attempted to execute Christa Pike, who had been convicted of a brutal 1995 murder.
They administered two doses of pentobarbital. But Pike kept breathing. Witnesses reported that she snored and occasionally lifted parts of her body from the gurney.
An ambulance eventually took her to a hospital.
She survived.
Imagine watching that unfold on live television.
What would the announcer say?
“We’re experiencing technical difficulties. Please stand by.”
And Tennessee is hardly alone. Electrocutions have required repeated jolts. Hangings have gone wrong. Lethal injections have left condemned prisoners struggling to breathe as executioners tried to finish the job.
A firing squad might be quicker. But bullets are no guarantee of an instantaneous, painless death.
I have written about the death penalty before. Nine years ago, I approached the subject from a rather different direction. (Full column in comments.)
My beloved beagle, Tyrone, was nearly 13. He had cancer, and his suffering had reached the point where my wife and I faced a decision no pet owner wants to make.
I took him to a veterinary hospital in Phoenix.
The veterinarian inserted a catheter into Tyrone’s front leg, then left us alone to say goodbye.
I talked to my old friend about the hundreds of miles we had walked together, about the coyotes we’d encountered, the rattlesnake and the jumping cholla cactus.
I cried. Tyrone looked up at me.
When the veterinarian returned, Tyrone was lying on a green blanket. I scratched him behind the ears as the doctor administered a sedative, followed by the medication that stopped his heart.
“Good-bye, buddy,” I told him. “You were a good boy.” I cried all the way home.
But Tyrone hadn’t suffered. He had died peacefully, surrounded by people who loved him.
And I found myself asking a question that still troubles me: Why can we give a dog a more humane death than we give a human being?
I understand the anger directed at Hasan. Thirteen people were murdered. Thirty-two others were wounded. Families were devastated. Nothing about the circumstances of his execution should diminish their suffering or the enormity of his crimes.
And reasonable people can disagree about whether the death penalty is justified.
But surely we can agree on something more fundamental. If the government is going to take a human life, it has at least a moral obligation and perhaps a constitutional one to do so with as little suffering as possible.
Not with the largest possible audience or corporate sponsors.
Not as the halftime show of a football game.
Now, look at that photograph from Owensboro in 1936.
Thousands gathered around the gallows, waiting to watch a man take his last breath.
Ninety years later, we don’t need to climb onto rooftops or stand in the summer heat.
We can watch from our living rooms. Or from a coffee shop on our iPhones.
We can even make popcorn.
But if we’re going to have executions in America, they should be more humane.
Not more entertaining.
Photo credits: Owensboro, Kentucky, Aug. 14, 1936: A crowd estimated at 20,000 gathers for the public hanging of Rainey Bethea. (Associated Press, via Santa Clara University Digital Exhibits)
Chat GPT-5.6 assisted in the production of this column.
Two months ago I upset a few Facebookers when I posted about the tragic death of 20-year-old Haitian Pierre Damas Bel in Springfield, Ohio.
“He FOLLOWED the rules,” I wrote. “He was legal.”
Several were quick to point out that Pierre remained in this country this summer AFTER the Trump administration ended the Temporary Protected Status that had allowed Haitians like him to stay. They argued that he was no longer allowed to be in Ohio..
But now I wonder if he had managed to live to see Tuesday’s election, if he could have maintained hope.
Pierre was born in Haiti, the oldest of three children. His parents left Haiti about three years before Pierre came to the United States. They bought a home in Springfield. Pierre remained behind in Haiti until 2024.
He came here at 18 to rejoin his family and continue his education.
He had no idea that his life soon would be unbearable.
I had no direct connection to Pierre, but I came to know hundreds of children like him through the writing of Emily Troutman, an AOL News reporter I supervised for a year while she covered Haiti after the devastating Jan. 12, 2010, earthquake.
Emily wrote dozens of heartbreaking stories about displaced children surviving in unsanitary, makeshift communities, including this excerpt from six months after the earthquake:
“There are now more than 1,300 camps. They are filled with 700,000 tarps and 100,000 tents. They are tied up alongside 8,000 cubic yards of rubble and 190,000 destroyed houses. There are 1.5 million people, including half a million children, in the streets.”
Then she asked Haitians what they had been doing lately.
“Nou leve chak jou, epi nou chita.”
In Creole: We get up every day, and we sit back down.
Pierre would have been 4 or 5 years old then.
He had been getting up every day and doing his best since arriving in America.
On March 5, 2024, Pierre made an appointment through the government’s CBP One program. He presented himself at a port of entry in Brownsville, Texas. He was released into the U.S. while his immigration case proceeded.
He enrolled at Springfield High School, where he became a National Honor Society student, a varsity soccer player and a member of the Marine Corps JROTC. He earned a scholarship. He worked at a local Texas Roadhouse, where coworkers thought enough of him to write character letters for his immigration case.
After graduating from Springfield High in May, Pierre enrolled at Wright State University. He was studying neuroscience and intended to go to medical school. He hoped to continue playing soccer.
He followed the rules.
Then Washington changed them.
The Trump administration moved to terminate Haiti’s Temporary Protected Status. On June 25, the Supreme Court cleared the way. The protection ended July 27.
Two days later, ICE placed Pierre in its Alternatives to Detention program and fitted him with a GPS ankle monitor while his immigration case continued.
The next day, Pierre wrote publicly about his “shame and humiliation.” He said he had come to America for an education, not to commit crimes or hurt anyone.
His father later said Pierre felt he was being treated “like an animal.”
Pierre didn’t just complain about the monitor.
His father said Pierre made two trips to immigration offices asking officials to remove it. He worried about attending college wearing it. He worried about playing soccer.
His father said students ridiculed him because of the monitor. Wright State says it has no confirmed information about complaints or investigations involving bullying.
On Aug. 24, Pierre began classes at Wright State.
He had made it.
Neuroscience. College. Maybe medical school.
Eight days later, at 8:03 on the morning of Aug. 31, Pierre video-called his father and told him he wasn’t doing well mentally. His father told him to come home so they could talk.
Pierre parked his Toyota on the shoulder of Interstate 70.
He never made it home.
So I stand by what I wrote on Facebook.
Pierre was legal. He followed the rules.
Then the rules changed.
It’s time to change them back, so we don’t lose any more Pierres.
(Chat GPT-5.6 contributed to the research and editing of this column. It also created the illustration.)
The earlier public record is notably consistent: Jon Husted discussed data centers as an economic-development opportunity to be recruited, incentivized and expanded. Explicit language about local residents making the choice appears much later, amid the political backlash.
The strongest evidence
2019 – Google/New Albany. Husted celebrated Google’s $600 million project, defended a 15-year state sales-tax exemption worth an estimated $43.5 million and argued that imposing the tax could have driven Google elsewhere. His emphasis was jobs, economic activity and making Columbus the Midwest technology hub. The contemporaneous Statehouse News Bureau account contains no mention of consulting residents beforehand or obtaining community consent.
2022 – Meta/New Albany expansion. Husted welcomed Meta’s expansion, saying Ohio valued the company’s continued investment and portraying tech infrastructure as Ohio’s future. New Albany Mayor Sloan Spalding discussed Meta’s community grants and called it a fantastic partner. Husted did not discuss resident input or approval.
June 2023 – AWS’s $7.8 billion expansion. DeWine and Husted announced the expansion while the communities where the new data centers would be built had not yet been selected. JobsOhio said numerous localities were under consideration and final sites would be determined later. Neither Husted’s statement nor the accompanying state economic-development message said those communities would first be consulted or allowed to decide whether they wanted the facilities.
August 2023 – Google expands to New Albany, Columbus and Lancaster. Husted appeared at Google’s announcement and again emphasized Ohio becoming the tech capital of the Midwest. Reporting noted the enormous electricity and transmission requirements of data centers, but Husted’s comments focused on investment and the lack of additional incentives, not community participation in the siting decision.
June 2024 – Husted recognizes the infrastructure problem. Husted acknowledged that Microsoft, AWS, Meta and other data centers demand large amounts of electricity and water for cooling and said Ohio needed a balance. When describing how the problem was being managed, however, he said the administration was in constant communication with AEP, the utility. He did not mention communications with affected residents, community votes or enhanced public participation. He then stressed that data centers generate local tax revenue without creating much housing demand.
June 2024 – Google’s $2.3 billion expansion. Husted’s formal quote was emphatic: “Data centers are essential to our digital lives.” He welcomed additional partnerships in education, AI and energy. His statement included no condition concerning resident approval or public consultation.
December 2024 – AWS announces another $10 billion. Husted said data centers and AI were “crucial to America’s economic superiority.” The state announcement describes the investment and economic benefits but contains no Husted call for local votes, resident consent or pre-siting public consultation.
Neither statement proves that Husted changed his position. Chronologically, however, this rhetoric differs markedly from the investment announcements of 2019-24.
Community-input concerns already existed
A 2022 critique of the closely related Intel/New Albany megaproject complained about secret negotiations and the absence of public input. Intel’s project is a semiconductor fabrication plant, not a data center, so it should not be treated as proof of Husted’s data-center policy. It does show that transparency and community participation were live issues surrounding the DeWine-Husted administration’s high-tech economic-development strategy.
TIME reported in 2022 that some longtime New Albany residents were worried about rapid development and objected to tax abatements for big-tech data centers because those projects generated relatively few permanent jobs. Husted, interviewed in the same story about the region’s technology boom, promoted the new high-tech economy; the account does not show him responding with a call for greater resident participation.
Husted used community listening in other policy areas
Community consultation was not foreign to Husted’s governing philosophy or administrative toolbox. BroadbandOhio used extensive public and stakeholder listening processes, including in-person and virtual sessions involving government, nonprofits, businesses and members of the public. Husted’s Common Sense Initiative likewise celebrated public and stakeholder input into regulations. What the reviewed record does not show is Husted publicly applying that approach to data-center siting during the years he was aggressively promoting the industry.
Husted now says he has “always believed” local communities should decide whether they want data centers. But a review of his public statements and Ohio economic-development announcements from 2019 through 2024 turns up no comparable call for resident approval or community consultation before data centers were sited. During those years, Husted repeatedly promoted data centers for their investment, tax revenue, jobs and importance to Ohio’s technology economy – even after acknowledging their enormous electricity and water demands.
The record reviewed does not support saying that Husted opposed community input. Nor does it establish that communities had no legal role; municipalities and townships often had zoning, annexation, infrastructure or tax decisions of their own.
The narrower question is more defensible: When Husted’s office now says he has always believed communities should decide, where is the contemporaneous evidence?
Among the major Google, Meta and AWS projects reviewed from 2019 through December 2024, no such public statement was located. The June 2023 AWS announcement is the strongest single exhibit: Ohio welcomed $7.8 billion in projects while the actual communities had yet to be selected, without Husted publicly conditioning the expansion on those communities wanting the facilities.
What if Dr. Anthony Fauci hadn’t taken the Fifth Amendment to every question in that televised circus they called a Senate hearing this week? What if instead of repeating the same legal sentence over and over, Fauci had answered the questions the way millions of Americans secretly wished someone would?
It might have gone something like this:
We pick it up after the curly-haired senator from Kentucky has blathered on for about 15 minutes in his opening remarks.
SEN. RAND PAUL: In 2004, you said the benefits of immunology research outweigh the risks. Do you still believe that?
DR. ANTHONY FAUCI: Do you still think the benefits outweigh the risks of having neighbors?
PAUL: Are you afraid to tell the truth?
FAUCI: I’ll tell it to Mitch McConnell.
PAUL: (exasperated) I yield to Senator Hawley.
SEN. JOSH HAWLEY: What day of the week is it?
FAUCI: The Fifth.
HAWLEY: What color is your tie.
FAUCI: On advice of counsel, I’d rather not discuss haberdashery.. HAWLEY: What color is the carpet?
FAUCI: You would know better than I would. You spent a lot of time running on it a few years ago.
HAWLEY: I must yield to Sen. Scott from Florida.
SEN. RICK SCOTT: “To your knowledge, sir, did Bill Gates partner with China on sensitive research?”
FAUCI: Senator, I think we’d both be better off if we skipped the healthcare résumés.
SCOTT: Uh, yeah, I yield to the Honorable John Kennedy of Louisiana. This should at least be entertaining.
SEN: TED CRUZ (raising his hand): I ask to be recognized.
PAUL: Everyone recognizes you, Ted.
CRUZ: I just wanted to apologize for being late. My flight from Cancun was delayed.
PAUL: You’re excused, Ted. Now go find your own committee. We were about to hear from Senator “There’s No F in This” Kennedy.
SEN. JOHN KENNEDY: Dr. Fauci, do you owe the American people an apology?
FAUCI: Do you apologize to nuns for suggesting people seek their advice about sex?
KENNEDY: This isn’t a comedy show, sir. Were you ever wrong?
FAUCI: Constantly. That’s why they call it research instead of religion.
KENNEDY: I yield to Senator Morono, er, Moreno from Ohio.
MORENO: Dr. Fauci, do you need a new car? Oh, wait, that’s for later. Where was I … oh, yes, I thought your six-foot rule was total crap.
FAUCI: Senator, are you saying there are never circumstances when you’d rather somebody stayed six feet away?
MORENO: This isn’t about my family, doctor. This is about re-litigating 2020. Who the F— did you think you were?
FAUCI: I thought I worked for Donald Trump.
(Looks around the room.)
You gentlemen seem to think Donald Trump worked for me.
PAUL: That’s enough. This hearing is adjourned.
FAUCI: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Oh, and Senator Hawley, I just remembered. The carpet is yellow. It’s not alone.
(ChatGPT-5 contributed to this column and produced the illustration.)
I confess. I celebrated America’s 250th birthday in Mexico. Not very patriotic of me, I suppose, but it was a lot cooler. Both the weather and the political temperature.
At least we tried to bribe a mariachi band into playing Bruce Springsteen’s “Born in the U.S.A”. They didn’t know it. We had to settle for “Sweet Caroline,” which all of the Americans in the Mexican restaurant knew by heart.
I doubt, though, that you really care that a former Ohio journalist spent his holiday out of the country. (At least I flew coach.)
You may care a little more about where someone asking Ohioans to elect him governor reportedly spent his.
According to The Rooster, a Columbus newsletter that has taken to tracking Vivek Ramaswamy’s private jet the way bird-watchers chase rare warblers, the candidate’s Bombardier Global 5500 left John Glenn Columbus International Airport at 10:20 on the night of July Fourth and landed at Paris-Le Bourget the following morning.
Or at least the airplane did.
We don’t actually know who was aboard.
Maybe FBI Director Kash Patel borrowed it for a quick champagne run, anticipating a U.S. victory after President Trump reinstated our soccer star. Who knows
Whatever happened, I can’t complain too loudly since I was out of the country myself.
Some people, however, think the optics matter. Cincinnati Enquirer guest columnist Nick Anderson argued the reported trip reflected the kind of detachment that enormous wealth like Ramswamy’s can produce.
Personally, I can’t understand why anyone would leave the Olentangy River for the Seine, though I’m not entirely sure even the natives know how to pronounce either one.
What does Paris have that Ohio doesn’t?
The French like Grey Poupon. Ohioans prefer Bertman’s Ballpark Mustard.
Advantage: Ohio.
Paris has Notre Dame. We have Big Butter Jesus. At least we had Him, until the 62-foot statue in Monroe, Ohio, was struck by lightning and destroyed in 2010. Notre Dame was almost destroyed, too, but has subsequently reopened. I guess God thought Big Butter was just too sacred to replace and rebuilt a steel structure, Hug Me Jesus, in its place.
You can cheer the dancers at the Folies Bergere in Paris, but is that really any comparison to following the follies at the Factory of Sadness in Cleveland, where the Browns turned the Can-Can into the Can’t-Can’t.
Paris has the Louvre, but Ohio has a legislature that treats ethics as an abstract art.
While the French have their haute couture, Ohio has the finest collection of Jim Jordan’s sweat-stained, short-sleeve shirts. You’ll have to wrestle those away from him, though.
And neither the French’s Chateaubriand nor that Cincinnati Skyline stuff vaguely resemble chili.
Truth be told, though, I’m glad I spent the Fourth in Cabo instead of Cleveland. I’d probably rather spend next year’s Fourth in Paris than Parma, too. Retirement comes with certain privileges.
Running for governor doesn’t.
When you’re asking 12 million Ohioans to hire you, every parade, every county fair, every VFW picnic, every church festival is more than another campaign stop. It’s your way of saying, These are my people. This is where I belong.
That’s why the issue isn’t whether Vivek Ramaswamy had the right to go to Paris – if he even did. (Photos show he attended at least one parade before his jet took off.) The issue is whether it was the right weekend to do it.
There are 364 perfectly good days each year to fall in love with Paris.
There is only one Fourth of July.
If you want to govern the Heart of It All, that’s when you ought to spend all weekend in the heart of it.
(Stuart Warner is a former editor at the Akron Beacon Journal, The Plain Dealer in Cleveland and the Arizona Republic. ChatGPT-5 contributed to the editing of this column.)
(You can almost imagine Jethro D. Vance swimmin’ in the cement pond)
Illustration by ChatGPT-5
With apologies to Flatt and Scruggs I present:
“The Ballad of Jed’s Cousin Don”
Come and listen to my story ’bout a man named Trump, Said the pool by his house looked like a D.C. dump. Then one day he decided to paint it blue, And suddenly he’d turned our water into goo. (Algae, that is. Pond scum. Green slime).
Well, the billionaires arrived to see what they could do. One suggested silver flakes, one suggested glue. RFK Jr.: “Ivermectin oughtta do the trick,” But the algae just got thicker and the smell got mighty sick. (Algae, that is. Pond scum. Green slime).
Trump blamed the mess on Democratic vandals, But after Epstein, he needed no more scandals. There were more arrests and arguments of state, But before too long the papers were callin’ it …
Water Gate. (Cover-ups, that is. Dirty tricks. Pond politics) Y’all come back now, ya hear?
I was sitting at the end of the bar at our local hangout, not sure if I wanted another drink or a better explanation of the world.
My pal Wired Al InCognito dropped a folded packet between us.
“Don’t,” I said.
“You haven’t even looked at it.”
“I’ve looked at enough documents.”
He smiled. “That’s what you said about the last one.”
I opened it anyway.
Project 8626.
“Where’d you get this?” I asked.
“Friend of a friend of an enemy of a friend,” he smiled.
“Nope,” I said, starting to fold it back up. “We’re not getting worked up again like we did over Project 2025.”
“We didn’t do anything last time,” Al said. “We read it. Nobody else did.”
“So what’s this supposed to mean, anyway? The Republicans have a grand plan for the year 8626? I don’t think even Trump can live that long.”
Al shook his head. “Don’t you know what ‘86’ means, paisan? In mob movies, ‘86’ is slang for getting rid of someone – eliminating them.”
“I’ve seen The Godfather at least 10 times and Goodfellas five,” I said. “Don’t remember hearing that number.”
“It’s not a number,” Al said. “It’s a command. Get rid of this mug. Eighty-six him.”
The bartender interrupted us. “Couldn’t help but overhear you guys. In restaurants, we use ‘86’ to mean we’re out of something – like fish, for example.”
“See,” Al said, grinning. “It means go sleep with the fishes.”
I couldn’t suppress a chuckle. “So the Republicans are going to get rid of the number 26.”
He glared at me. “The ’26 elections, dummy.”
That stopped me for a moment.
“Voting rights?” I said.
Al nodded. “You saw what the Supreme Court did this week.”
I started flipping through the document, stopping at a section titled “Getting Out the Vote.” It went on about how minorities and women shouldn’t have special voting rights. How race shouldn’t determine congressional district boundaries. How you should have to register under your name and sex assigned at birth. And maybe how we should even suspend primaries until their new rules are set.
“We used to talk about access for all,” I said.
“Back when the Voting Rights Act of 1965 was the point,” Al said.
“This feels different,” I said.
“How?”
“Less about getting people to vote,” I said. “More about making sure everything lines up once they do.”
Al raised his glass. “Now you’re getting it.”
I kept reading.
There was a section about authority. Another about providing security at the polls. Voter IDs to prevent rampant fraud.
“Funny thing,” I said.
“What?”
“There’s at least one justice up there who probably doesn’t get that robe if the Voting Rights Act doesn’t exist.”
“And he’s the loudest voice behind this,” Al said.
The tall, lanky guy two stools down gave a knowing laugh.
“Yeah,” he said. “That’s not irony. That’s efficiency.”
I closed the packet halfway.
“This is the same playbook.”
Al shook his head. “No.”
“What?”
“It’s cleaner,” he said. “Less explaining. Besides, they’ve already done most of the stuff they said they’d do to us in the first one.”
“You’re saying this is the next version.”
“I’m saying they don’t need to write it all down anymore. The court is doing that for them.”
The guy two stools down raised his glass.
“You guys still think this is about stopping elections,” he said.
There was something about the way he said it – calm, precise – like he was used to being listened to.
“It’s not,” he said. “It’s about controlling everything around them.”
I turned to look at Al, as if to say, “Who is this guy.” Then I turned back. The stranger was gone. He glass was empty.
I stared at the packet, pushed it back across the bar toward Al.
“So what do we do?”
“Same as last time,” Al said.
“Which was?”
“Read it. Write it. Explain it.”
“And when nobody believes it because the president says he knows nothing about it?”
Al smiled.
“Then we’ll be right again later.”
We sat there watching the game, arguing about whether the digital umpire got that strike right.
“The people in Hungary showed us that voting still matters,” I said.
“Yeah? They realized what was at stake. Do we?”
“Maybe,” I said.
Al sat quietly for a moment. Then he looked back and me. It was no joke this time when he said:
“If we don’t, democracy may be sleeping with the fishes.”
(Note: Project 8626 isn’t real. Yet. ChatGPT-5 assisted in writing this column.)
We need something to make us happy right now so I asked my digital pal Wired Al if we could collaborate on song that could get us tapping our toes. When oil starts moving and explanations start dancing, it’s usually time to listen to the music.
This week’s melody comes courtesy of calypso, a genre designed in places where power strutted in uninvited, taking what it wanted. That tradition runs straight through Harry Belafonte, whose cheerful songs were often about theft, betrayal and the kind of authority that laughs while picking your pocket.
Fast-forward to now, where foreign policy increasingly sounds like a real estate pitch delivered through a bullhorn. Venezuelan oil is rebranded as a strategic necessity. Greenland becomes a punch line that won’t die. Colombia and Mexico are name-checked the way middle managers talk about “synergy” – vaguely, loudly, and with complete confidence that someone else will clean it up. None of this is framed as conquest. It’s framed as leadership. Boss moves. Executive decisions made while the band plays on.
Which brings us to the song. Belafonte’s Matilda, which was a folk tale about a thief who ran off with the money. But theft, like everything else, has been promoted. Today it wears a suit, demands applause, and insists the chorus keep singing.
So sing along with Harry and Wired Al on the chorus of Boss Donald.
OPENING CHORUS
ALL (cheerful, loud):
Boss Donald … Boss Donald … Boss Donald He take the oil and ran Venezuela.
Once again now!
Boss Donald … Boss Donald … Boss Donald, He take the oil and ran Venezuela
VERSE 1 — GOOD INTENTIONS
Five hundred slogans, friends, I lost: “Energy freedom” – cheap words, high cost.
LEAD (grinning): Boss Donald –
ALL: He take the oil and ran Venezuela.
Everybody now ..
(Boss Donald!) Sing out the chorus! (Boss Donald!) Sing a little louder!
ALL: Boss Donald,he take the oil and ran Venezuela
VERSE 2 — EMPIRE SHOPPING
Well, the oil was to buy “strength and pride,” A house, a flag, a border wide.
Said, “Trust me, friends, I have a plan,” Then waved a pen, said, “Watch out, Iran.”
ALL: Boss Donald, he take the oil and ran Venezuela
GREENLAND BREAK (classic calypso aside)
CROWD (shouting): Can we have Greenland?
LEAD (matter-of-fact): Not for sale.
ALL (right back to melody): Boss Donald, he take the oil and ran Venezuela.
VERSE 3 — LEGAL MAGIC
Well, the oil was just inside our bed, In “strategic reserves,” the lawyers said.
Buried deep in a footnote thread— Stamped temporary, signed, unread.
LEAD: Don’t you know—
ALL: Boss Donald, he found the oil and…
EVERYBODY: Ran Venezuela!
RHYTHM CHANT
(Boss Donald!) Oom-ba-locka-chimba! (Boss Donald!) Bring me talking points!
Boss Donald, he take the oil and ran Venezuela
VERSE 4 — CONSEQUENCES, MINIMIZED
Well, me friends, never to ask again, All me norms gone down the drain.
He may want Mexico, too. Colombia: We’re watching you.
ALL: Boss Donald, he take the oil and ran Venezuela
FINAL BUILD (soft → loud)
ALL (soft): Boss Donald… Boss Donald… Boss Donald…
He take the oil and ran Venezuela.
Sing it softer now…
Boss Donald, Boss Donald, Boss Donald, he take the oil and ran Venezuela
BIG FINISH
EVERYBODY (full voice): Boss Donald ,… sing out the chorus! Boss Donald, he take the oil and ran Venezuela!
CROWD (last shout): Can we have Greenland?
LEAD Still not for sale.
BAND CRASH. END.
Of course, you music historians know that calypso didn’t start as entertainment. It started as information, originating in Trinidad and Tobago in the 18th and 19th centuries among enslaved Africans. When colonial authorities banned drums and restricted speech, people did what humans always do under pressure: they found another channel. Rhythm replaced the drum. Melody replaced the shout. Lyrics carried news, warnings, insults and political commentary in plain sight, disguised as song.
And it’s appropriate today because Trinidad and Tobago are the southernmost Caribbean nations, just off the Venezuelan coast.
Perfectly placed to see empire coming before it arrived.
Boss Donald … he take the oil and ran Venezuela.
(Chat GPT-5 produced the illustration and collaborated on the column.)